Sunday, November 18, 2007

Truth is Complicated -- For Republicans

David Brooks of the NYTimes wrote a column last week in praise of Reagan that has reverberated through the Times and elsewhere. The latest foray is an op-ed piece in today's Times by Reagan author Lou Cannon.

The original piece by Paul Krugman on the Jena 6 in September mentioned the racial tone of "southern white exceptionalism," in Politics in Black and White:

But the reality is that things haven’t changed nearly as much as people think. Racial tension, especially in the South, has never gone away, and has never stopped being important. And race remains one of the defining factors in modern American politics.

* * * *

Republican politicians, who understand quite well that the G.O.P.’s national success since the 1970s owes everything to the partisan switch of Southern whites, have tacitly acknowledged this reality. Since the days of Gerald Ford, just about every Republican presidential campaign has included some symbolic gesture of approval for good old-fashioned racism.

Thus Ronald Reagan, who began his political career by campaigning against California’s Fair Housing Act, started his 1980 campaign with a speech supporting states’ rights delivered just outside Philadelphia, Miss., where three civil rights workers were murdered. In 2000, Mr. Bush made a pilgrimage to Bob Jones University, famed at the time for its ban on interracial dating.
Brooks response was curious, in that it takes up an issue that is hardly topical for the GOP. In History and Calumny, Brooks attempts to redefine Reagan's use of Nixon's "Southern Strategy" during his presidential campaign, calling it an erroneous myth:
Today, I’m going to write about a slur. It’s a distortion that’s been around for a while, but has spread like a weed over the past few months. It was concocted for partisan reasons: to flatter the prejudices of one side, to demonize the other and to simplify a complicated reality into a political nursery tale.

The distortion concerns a speech Ronald Reagan gave during the 1980 campaign in Philadelphia, Miss., which is where three civil rights workers had been murdered 16 years earlier. An increasing number of left-wing commentators assert that Reagan kicked off his 1980 presidential campaign with a states’ rights speech in Philadelphia to send a signal to white racists that he was on their side. The speech is taken as proof that the Republican majority was built on racism.

The truth is more complicated.

It is? I always thought that the truth was based upon facts. It only gets complicated when you have to go through gyrations to re-engineer the facts to fit the spin of the day.

Apparently, this is Brooksworld, where truth is complicated. It's complicated because it's not easy to re-write the history of the GOP's Southern Strategy and Reagan's role in that strategy. Brooks tries to explain that Reagan stopped in Philadelphia, Miss. on his way to New York from Chicago merely because he was in the neighborhood, rather than because he intended to send a signal to southern racists by starting his campaign at a county fair there. As he notes:

You can look back on this history in many ways. It’s callous, at least, to use the phrase “states’ rights” in any context in Philadelphia. Reagan could have done something wonderful if he’d mentioned civil rights at the fair. He didn’t. And it’s obviously true that race played a role in the G.O.P.’s ascent.

Still, the agitprop version of this week — that Reagan opened his campaign with an appeal to racism — is a distortion, as honest investigators ranging from Bruce Bartlett, who worked for the Reagan administration and is the author of “Impostor: How George W. Bush Bankrupted America and Betrayed the Reagan Legacy,” to Kevin Drum, who writes for Washington Monthly, have concluded.

But still the slur spreads. It’s spread by people who, before making one of the most heinous charges imaginable, couldn’t even take 10 minutes to look at the evidence. It posits that there was a master conspiracy to play on the alleged Klan-like prejudices of American voters, when there is no evidence of that conspiracy. And, of course, in a partisan age there are always people eager to believe this stuff.

So facts -- otherwise known as "slurs" -- have this nasty habit of intruding on the spin. After all, no reasonable person would believe that pandering to the southern white crowd what Reagan intended in Mississippi. Those were the old facts, since replaced by the new version. Actually, the "whitewashing" (apt phrase that, no?) of history began shortly after Reagan died in 2004. At that time, as Steven Gilliard wrote, in his THE NEWS BLOG:
First, Reagan rode to power on a wave of reaction to the Civil Rights struggle. California, a state with a deep well of racial resentment, supported Reagan, who would protect the establishment and call for students to be murdered on their campuses. Reagan was regarded as a crank by many on the left, but his appeal to middle America was strong. It wasn't that Reagan was a racist, as fas as is known, he wasn't. But he sure could pander to them, as he did in [1980] at Philadelphia, MS. For those of you unaware, that is the place three civil rights workers were murdered by the Klan. It would be like a British Prime Ministerial candidate going to Amritsar to talk about the glory of the British Army (the site of a 1921 massacre of peaceful Indian protesters). Reagan pandered to the racist right with ease, even as Barry Goldwater, the man he supported in 1964 with a convention speech, slowly backed away from many of his reactionary views. Instead, Reagan depicted blacks as 'welfare queens' leeching off the society, when in reality, white women are the largest recipients of AFDC. Reagan used race like a club to hammer minorities and pander to the racist right.
Even Ken Melhman, former Chair of the RNC, acknowledged and apologized (sort of) for the GOP's decade's long Southern Strategy, saying:
"Some Republicans gave up on winning the African-American vote, looking the other way or trying to benefit politically from racial polarization," said Mr. Mehlman. "I am here today as the Republican chairman to tell you we were wrong."
Of course, he was criticized for suggesting that those days were over for the Republican Party. See, An Empty Apology. Yet, at least he didn't try to deny that it occurred in the recent history of the GOP.

After Brooks' tit, Krugman responded with a tat, which eviscerated, as only he could, the unnamed "campaign on to exonerate Ronald Reagan from the charge that he deliberately made use of Nixon’s Southern strategy." In his blog, The Conscience of a Liberal, Krugman labeled Reagan's missteps as a series of Innocent mistakes, as he scathingly recalls:
When he went to Philadelphia, Mississippi, in 1980, the town where the civil rights workers had been murdered, and declared that “I believe in states’ rights,” he didn’t mean to signal support for white racists. It was all just an innocent mistake.

Indeed, you do really have to feel sorry for Reagan. He just kept making those innocent mistakes.

When he went on about the welfare queen driving her Cadillac, and kept repeating the story years after it had been debunked, some people thought he was engaging in race-baiting. But it was all just an innocent mistake.

When, in 1976, he talked about working people angry about the “strapping young buck” using food stamps to buy T-bone steaks at the grocery store, he didn’t mean to play into racial hostility.

* * * *

Similarly, when Reagan declared in 1980 that the Voting Rights Act had been “humiliating to the South,” he didn’t mean to signal sympathy with segregationists. It was all an innocent mistake.

In 1982, when Reagan intervened on the side of Bob Jones University, which was on the verge of losing its tax-exempt status because of its ban on interracial dating, he had no idea that the issue was so racially charged. It was all an innocent mistake.

And the next year, when Reagan fired three members of the Civil Rights Commission, it wasn’t intended as a gesture of support to Southern whites. It was all an innocent mistake.

Poor Reagan. He just kept on making those innocent mistakes, again and again and again.

Next up was Bob Herbert, providing historical context to the silent battle between the Times columnists. As he notes in Righting Reagan’s Wrongs?:

The murders were among the most notorious in American history. They constituted Neshoba County’s primary claim to fame when Reagan won the Republican Party’s nomination for president in 1980. The case was still a festering sore at that time. Some of the conspirators were still being protected by the local community. And white supremacy was still the order of the day.

That was the atmosphere and that was the place that Reagan chose as the first stop in his general election campaign. . . .

Reagan apologists have every right to be ashamed of that appearance by their hero, but they have no right to change the meaning of it, which was unmistakable. Commentators have been trying of late to put this appearance by Reagan into a racially benign context.

* * * *

Everybody watching the 1980 campaign knew what Reagan was signaling at the fair. Whites and blacks, Democrats and Republicans — they all knew. The news media knew. The race haters and the people appalled by racial hatred knew. And Reagan knew.

He was tapping out the code. It was understood that when politicians started chirping about “states’ rights” to white people in places like Neshoba County they were saying that when it comes down to you and the blacks, we’re with you.

And Reagan meant it. He was opposed to the landmark Civil Rights Act of 1964, which was the same year that Goodman, Schwerner and Chaney were slaughtered. As president, he actually tried to weaken the Voting Rights Act of 1965. He opposed a national holiday for the Rev. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. He tried to get rid of the federal ban on tax exemptions for private schools that practiced racial discrimination. And in 1988, he vetoed a bill to expand the reach of federal civil rights legislation.

Despite Brooks' essay, this was not just one instance of a slip by Reagan that was misconstrued by his visit to Philadelphia, Miss. As these series of unfortunate, but true, facts show, other instances abound. See also, Krugman v Brooks and Reagan’s ‘Mistaken’ Legacy of Racism.

With the facts against them, it is obviously time for a change of tactics. The latest is that these mean old liberals are trying to portray Reagan as a divisive racist.

Today's op-ed, by Lou Cannon, takes up that mantle, in Reagan’s Southern Stumble, with the observation: "Any fair-minded look at Mr. Reagan’s biography and record demonstrates that he was not a bigot. " Of course, this line is followed by a litany of examples, in the vein of "some of his best friends were black."

Apparently, this must be the flavor de jour , since Krugman also comments at his blog, Signs of desperation:

This represents a level of misunderstanding that has to be deliberate:

Enough already. Nobody believes Reagan is a bigot.

That is, of course, not the question. Reagan’s personal attitude is of no consequence. The question is whether he deliberately appealed to bigots, as a political tactic. And he did.

Personally, before the Republicans go too far down that path, I'm not sure how much this excuse helps. In my view, it almost makes it worse. Is it better that Reagan actually understood the effects of bigotry, yet acquiesced by knowingly taking advantage of those who subscribe to those beliefs, to the detriment of those who suffered at the hands of racism? I think not.

Rather, as noted by Canadian blogger Sans Everything, I think the words of Southern writer Eudora Welty, who lived in Mississippi, Eudora Welty on Reagan in Mississippi, are appropo:
Welty said in an interview she gave in 1985: “Mississippi is very conservative …. Reagan carried the state because he came down there and he talked about ‘We’ll be having states’ rights’ and a whole lot of things like that. You know that was very wicked of him.”

Welty was a lady of the old school. She never raised her voice and always used words precisely. When she said “wicked” she meant “wicked” with all its full and terrible connotations. (Emphasis added).

For a detailed of Brooks' position, see Driftglass' "A Rose for Bobo", (the 1st of 4 parts). See also, Group News Blog.

Saturday, November 17, 2007

Cartoon of the Day


* Nick Anderson, Houston Chronicle

Definitely Diamonds & Pearls


Do you prefer diamonds or pearls?

I want both.

I must confess that I haven't watched (endured) any of the Presidential debates to date. I have read about the issues (silly and otherwise) that were addressed and have watched a few video clips on some of the topics that were covered. The format for the debates certainly isn't likely to elicit much more than an occasional sound bite. The other part of it is, living in Pennsylvania, I know my primary vote won't count. So I hate to get too invested in it all, only to have my hopes dashed.

However, when I saw the headlines about "Diamonds or Pearls" after the last debate, I had to find out what happened. As noted in Behind Clinton’s Diamonds and Pearls:

At last night’s Democratic presidential debate, the candidates faced questions on Pakistan, trade policy, and merit pay for teachers. . . . [A]t the close of the debate, Senator Hillary Clinton was asked what sort of jewelry she liked?

“Do you prefer diamonds or pearls?” Maria Luisa Parra-Sandoval, one of several audience members who posed questions, asked her.

“I want both,” Mrs. Clinton replied to laughter.

After the laughter came the clamor -- charges of sexism, of favoritism and other assorted stupid nonsense. As the article noted:

Now Ms. Parra-Sandoval is being accused, by everyone from bloggers to fellow students, of asking an airheaded, sexist question. On her MySpace page and in a phone interview, she protested that she tried to ask several substantive questions but that CNN would only let her participate through a silly one.

See also, Diamonds And Pearls Are A Girl's Best Friend (But Maybe Not Her Question Of Choice). Of course, the words of waitress Anita Esterday from last week's brouhaha were soon forgotten -- the press needs to get a perspective on what really matters. See Iowa Waitress Speaks Out: I Didn't Get Tip From Clinton, Media Has Misplaced Priorities.

Can't we be at a lighthearted anymore? Is everything (except the important issues of the day) the subject of scrutiny ad nauseum, ad infinitum??

Having said all that, I have to add that Hillary's answer was right on. This was not waffling on her part. That was the only correct response.

Anyone who knows me, knows that my one true love (after my family, of course) is jewelry. It's what I'm known for. My legal career is just a sideline in comparison. Jewelry by Judi could be the name of my business in my next career. It probably would not be an exaggeration to say that I have more jewelry than some jewelry stores. I've included a few of my favorite diamonds and pearls (including my Tahitian black pearls, of course) in the photo above, to give a sampling.
Although Prince is not my favorite musician, I thought it only appropriate to include his "Diamonds and Pearls"

Nobody Does It Better

She wasn't a very good lawyer, she didn't bill enough, she had no clients. And worst of all -- she didn't have a good personality and wasn't a very good dancer. No, we're not talking dating partners, we're talking legal partners who sour on each other. Of course, nobody does it better than lawyers on the attack.

This is an update on the latest on the attorney from the Delaware County office of Cozen & O'Connor, Patricia Biswanger, who sued the firm for sex discrimination after being terminated, that I covered last month, Legal Tales. As noted in the Legal Intelligencer, Cozen O'Connor: Lawyer Suing for Sex Discrimination Was Fired for 'Poor Judgment':

Cozen O'Connor has fired back at a woman lawyer who filed a sex discrimination suit against the firm, saying in its formal answer to the suit that she was fired for "poor judgment and poor decision-making" and for continuing to violate firm rules even after she was placed on probation.

* * * *

While Biswanger claims that she was punished by the firm for her "political involvement," the firm's answer denies that characterization. "Firm attorneys may engage in political activities on behalf of themselves as individuals, but are restricted from engaging in political activities on behalf of the firm without advance approval."

Biswanger's use of firm letterhead and e-mail in her own political battles, the answer says, "suggested that her personal views were supported by the firm," and gave the appearance that the firm "was representing individuals who were not clients of the firm."

In the suit, Biswanger claims that during her nearly seven years at the firm, her work was consistently rated as "excellent" or "outstanding," and that she was routinely given generous raises and bonuses that were "among the largest awarded" to the firm's junior members.

But the firm, in its answer, suggests that Biswanger exaggerated the quality of her performance.

"During portions of her employment with the firm, Ms. Biswanger's performance of some of her duties met or exceeded the firm's expectations of attorneys of her experience and status," the answer says.

But the answer says the firm "denies that Ms. Biswanger represented the firm's 'most prominent' clients in 'substantial' matters because these terms are vague and undefined. The firm regards all of its clients as 'prominent' and it treats all matters as 'substantial.'"

The answer also says the firm denies that Biswanger ever received an "excellent" evaluation because "the firm's evaluation system does not contain a rating titled 'excellent.'"

As for Biswanger's claim that she received a salary increase that was among the highest in the firm, the answer says that Biswanger's salary increase was "modest."

Love the response. The legalisms are just too perfect, such as she couldn't have received an "excellent" evaluation because we don't have such a rating. Humm, I wonder what term they use instead to distinguish between average and excellent lawyers? Above average? Superlawyers? And I truly love: all clients are "prominent" and all matters are "substantial."

On the other hand, as much as I love the fuss & muss, I must concede that it sounds like Biswanger may have gotten involved in some nasty politics in Havertown Township, which ended up raising the ire of then President Judge Clouse. I don't blame Cozen for not wanting to get involved in that sort of battle. After all, they are a litigation firm that has to appear before the bench in Delaware County. Doesn't help your client to have the Judge as a sworn enemy of the firm or its lawyers.

And because they didn't want to miss out on the fun, Philly firm also Ballard Spahr decided to one-up Cozen & O'Connor in the law partner legal divorce front, which resulted in its own gender discrimination lawsuit. This one, however, makes the Biswanger case look like baby stuff. In a case involving a female partner in its Baltimore office, the Legal Intelligencer states, Ballard Spahr Fails to Halt Gender Discrimination Claim:
After attempting to resolve internally alleged issues of inequitable pay and the piecemeal removal of her practice over the course of a decade, Jane Ennis Sheehan had confidentially presented on May 9 gender discrimination claims and a demand letter to Ballard Spahr Chairman Arthur Makadon through her counsel, according to court documents from both sides.

Sheehan claimed that another partner who was supposed to be her equal in a two-person team took her practice from her over the course of several years and called it his own. That partner was ultimately paid more for doing the same work, she said in her demand letter.

She also claimed in the letter that she was retaliated against for bringing these claims to light internally, eventually resulting in her being taken from a percentage or equity partner to an income partner.
The best part is that after they were unable to resolve the matter during the course of a conference call with the various parties and their counsel:
The next day, Ballard Spahr filed an action for declaratory judgment in Philadelphia Common Pleas Court, arguing that the firm had not violated Sheehan's rights under the Equal Pay Act and had not breached any fiduciary duty.
You know -- the lawyer version of the scorched earth policy as a way of dispute resolution. The ABA Journal explained it well, Ballard Spahr Stumbles in Race to Court:
A Philadelphia judge has ruled that a law firm’s attempt to head off a gender discrimination complaint is premature.

Judge Gary DiVito ruled Sept. 24 that Ballard Spahr Andrews & Ingersoll could not obtain declaratory relief “in anticipation of an action at law by another party,” the Legal Intelligencer reports. He said administrative remedies must be exhausted first.

The firm filed the suit May 31 seeking a decision that it had not violated equal pay rights or a fiduciary duty to Baltimore real-estate partner Jane Ennis Sheehan. The suit was filed a day after lawyers held a conference call to discuss a resolution to Sheehan’s complaints.

Sheehan claims she was supposed to be an equal on a two-partner team, but the male partner took over her practice and was paid more for doing the same work, the Legal Intelligencer says. Her demand letter said she was downgraded from an equity partner to an income partner after she brought her complaints to light.

After the firm filed the lawsuit, Sheehan filed a discrimination complaint with the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.
I guess it's the 2007 version of the 1984 Hishon v. King & Spalding case, which (unsuccessfully) argued that sex discrimination laws don't apply to law firms. Of course, the law firm couldn't have known that it couldn't stop the lawsuit before it started. It's a law firm. We all know that the laws don't really apply to lawyers. We just apply them to others.

Tags: ,

Suckface

When my daughter was younger, I joined Live Journal and MySpace so that I could monitor her on-line activities. I especially wanted to make sure that she was not revealing too much personal information or allowing strangers to contact her.

Now, she's part of the Facebook crowd and when I tried to join that network, she immediately sent me a message:

MOM!! UR NOT SUPPOST TO HAVE A FACE BOOK!! WHAT ARE U DOIN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
!!!!! DELETE THISSS
I figured that since she was now 17, I guess I should respect her privacy (to the extent that there is any privacy on the internet). And I am a strong proponent of privacy rights (I do honor her right to privacy off-line -- I would never read her diary or letters). Also, there was no way she was going to add me to her list of "friends" so I was out of luck anyway. Beyond that, at this point in my life, there was no reason for me to do Facebook. See My Midlife Facebook Crisis.

As much as I love technology and the untold benefits from many of the technological advances that have arisen in the past few years, one major downside is the erosion of our privacy (even beyond the encroachment by the governmental authorities in charge these days).

I am by nature a private person. That's at least in part why I blog under a pseudonym.* I am careful about the personal matters that I discuss, so that I do not reveal too much information about myself, my family or friends that could prove embarrassing or intrusive.

The evolution of the internet, for many, is anything but private. See, e.g., Who's Watching Now?. The examples are legend about the pictures posted and revelations made on social networking sites that later cost jobs or reputations.

The latest wrinkle in the diminution of our personal privacy is the new campaign by Facebook to adopt an advertising technique that relies on user-provided details about themselves for marketers to target their ads. Fortunately, legal issues have been raised regarding the usage, see Are Facebook’s Social Ads Illegal?. As the WSJ Law Blog explains, in Facebook Faces Legal Questions Over "Facebook Ads":

On their respective blogs — here and here — GWU Law professor Dan Solove and Minnesota Law professor William McGeveran have issues with the new program. McGeveran points out that this may be illegal under a 100-year-old New York privacy law. The statute says that “any person whose name, portrait, picture, or voice is used within this state for advertising purposes or for the purposes of trade without the written consent first obtained” can sue for damages. What’s more, such a use is a criminal misdemeanor.

The New York law would apply to Facebook users anywhere if the ad were displayed in New York, says McGeveran. He also says that people can sue advertisers who use their names and images without permission under the legal doctrine of missappropriation — “One who appropriates to his own use or benefit the name or likeness of another is subject to liability to the other for an invasion of his privacy.” But unlike celebrities, the average Facebook user would have a hard time proving damages — i.e, that their reputation has been sullied or that they were deprived of endorsement fees.

See also, New Facebook Ad Techniques Raise Privacy Concerns. Of course, as noted, the laws are not exactly the most protective, but even worse is the probably true observation that teens and young adults most likely won't even be upset by this.

The method that Facebook is using, however, is especially offensive, as reported by the WSJ Law Blog, More On the Law Blog's Facebook Foray:

Last Sunday the Law Blog purchased three tickets to “Bee Movie” on Fandango, the movie site. After we did this, Facebook automatically updated our profile to say, “Peter bought ‘Bee Movie’ on Fandango.”

Apparently, buried in all of the privacy settings and terms of use for Facebook and Fandango were the authorizations to gather and use your personal information. As Daniel Solove of Concurring Opinions said, The Facebook-Fandango Connection: Invasion of Privacy?:

This case illustrates why the current legal regime regulating personal information at most websites is so deeply flawed. The default settings are set to allow information sharing and disclosure, with users often completely unaware of how their information is going to be used. Businesses frequently tout how they are protecting privacy by providing users with "notice and choice" about how their information will be collected, used, and disseminated. Yet the system rarely results in informed consumers or meaningful choices.

So imagine: You go to Fandango and buy tickets to see a movie -- and then all of a sudden your purchase is being revealed publicly to everybody you know on Facebook. You probably didn't even know that Facebook had this deal with Fandango. What if more websites like Fandango start to collude with Facebook? Does this mean that every time we visit a website, every time we make a purchase, the information starts showing up in our Facebook profiles and on our friends' Facebook profiles?

And Facebook's response to all of this? Very dismissive, not surprisingly. According to the WSJ Law Blog:
A Facebook spokeswoman gave us a response: “Facebook’s Terms of Use provides the consent that the law requires. Social Ads is a fundamentally new type of advertising that puts users in control and displays relevant referrals from friends about the products and services they recommend.”
Short of abandoning the network altogether (which I'm sure teens won't do as long as their friends still hang there), perhaps the best response is to give a big thumbs down or U SUCK for any ad that's used with their name. I assume there's a way to link back to that person who's "endorsing" the product. The link can then pan the product. That would certainly cut short that particular method of advertising, I would think.

____________________

* Of course, to be honest, as I've mentioned before, the main reason I do not reveal my is that most of my clients do not share my liberal leanings and I certainly don't want to allow my hobby to impact my business. I Hardly Knew You.

Monday, November 12, 2007

The Odd Couple

While everyone was amazed at the coupling of Pat Robertson and Rudy Giuliani, through Robertson's surprising endorsement of Giuliani last week, In stunner, Pat Robertson endorses Giuliani, for me the truly astounding pairing was that of Bill Clinton and Richard Mellon Scaife, So Happy Together.

Now Robertson has got to be one of the sickest puppies I've seen in a long time. Rudy better heed this advice: Don't Drink The Kool-Aid with the man -- for my money, Robertson puts Jim Jones to shame. Nonetheless, he's also a scam artist extraordinaire; he wants to be on the winning team, so he'll go with the Giuliani.

The really odd couple is Clinton/Scaife. Scaife spent many years and mucho dollars funding the "Arkansas Project" and other ventures to dig up dirt on the Clintons. Although they both belong to the "women trouble club," especially with Scaife's nasty divorce, see Mr. Mellonhead, that can't explain the friendly lunch they recently shared:

Clinton, pouring on the charm, greeted Scaife like an old friend. "President Clinton believes in redemption and moving forward," says spokeswoman Jennifer Hanley. Ruddy says they talked about Clinton's charitable work and avoided opening old wounds. After receiving the full Bill treatment, Scaife left with a new outlook on the man he had once set out to crush. Scaife isn't ready to sign on to Hillary's campaign—he's still a Republican. But his lawyer, Yale Gutnick, says Bill Clinton and Richard Mellon Scaife are now members of a "mutual admiration society." Cue the apocalypse.
Who knows -- after the mess of things Bush made, I guess Clinton looks good in Scaife's view. For his part, I'm sure Clinton would be happy to neutralize his major nemesis so Hillary doesn't have to deal with the same unrelenting smear tactics during her campaign and after -- if there is an after.

Tags:

Cartoon of the Day


Bob Englehart, Hartford Courant

Sunday, November 11, 2007

It's Not Just a Day


Support the Troops, be sue to wear the American Flag Pin, and above all, shop till you drop at the Mall -- all the slogans to go with the celebration of Veterans Day. But for the real vets, it's not just a day.

I may be a pacifist, and would prefer to avoid war at all costs, but I do believe that we need to honor and respect those who have served on behalf of our country, at our request. Despite the slogans, we are not doing that. There was the scandal regarding Walter Reed Hospital last February, see (Don't Worry) If There's Hell Below . . ., which has not really been fixed. As the Boston globe reported:

EVEN AS our government puts members of our armed services in harm's way, it is failing to care for them once they return home. Soldiers get excellent acute care when injured on active duty, but as revelations of poor conditions for soldiers receiving ongoing outpatient care at the Walter Reed Army Medical Center highlighted, service members often have trouble getting the care they need once active duty ends.

According to a study by some of my colleagues at Harvard Medical School, to be published in next month's American Journal of Public Health, nearly 1.8 million veterans had no health insurance in 2004, up 290,000 since 2000. An additional 3.8 million members of their households were also uninsured and ineligible for care at hospitals and clinics run by the Veterans Health Administration of the Department of Veterans Affairs. The 2006 data released this year show little change in these numbers.

See Healthcare for vets - and all others. A NYTimes editorial echoed this situation, Veterans Without Health Care:
Although many Americans believe that the nation’s veterans have ready access to health care, that is far from the case. A new study by researchers at the Harvard Medical School has found that millions of veterans and their dependents have no access to care in veterans’ hospitals and clinics and no health insurance to pay for care elsewhere. Their plight represents yet another failure of our disjointed health care system to provide coverage for all Americans.

* * * *

Most of the uninsured veterans were working-class people who were too poor to afford private insurance but not poor enough to qualify for care under a priority system administered by the Veterans Affairs Department. Some were unable to get care because there was no V.A. facility nearby, or the nearest facility had a long waiting list, or they could not afford the co-payments required of some veterans.

There is little doubt that lack of coverage was deleterious to their health. Like other uninsured Americans, the uninsured veterans report that they have delayed or forgone care because of costs. Half had not seen a doctor in the past year, and two-thirds got no preventive care.

And the situation has been getting worse. Despite a shrinking population of working-age veterans, the number of uninsured veterans increased by 290,000 between 2000 and 2004, propelled by a steady erosion of health care coverage in the workplace and a tightening of enrollment criteria for veterans’ care.

The V.A. has long focused on caring for recent combat veterans, those with service-connected disabilities or special needs and the poorest veterans. Other veterans were served to the extent that resources were available. Unfortunately, in recent years enrollment of higher-income, nondisabled veterans shot up so fast that long waiting lists developed and budgets failed to keep pace, forcing a freeze on enrollments in this category.

And, of course, to add insult to injury, there is the problem of homelessness that is afflicting our returning vets. As Carol Hoenig at Huffington Post said, Revered but Homeless -- Our Veterans:

On this Veteran's Day, let's be sure to wear our American flag pins in honor of our war heroes. In addition, let's drive our gas-guzzling vehicles to the mall, pull out our over-extended credit card, and spend money we don't have on a new mattress or an upgraded DVD player, thanks to those ubiquitous Veteran's Day sales! After all, this is how we are asked to support our troops, right? Never mind that the National Alliance to End Homelessness reports that veterans make up one-quarter of the homeless population.

Knowing this, can we really celebrate Veteran's Day? Maybe we should instead focus on fixing these problems for those who gave of themselves in the service of our country, which would be the better way to offer our thanks.

(Cartoon by Nick Anderson, Houston Chronicle)

Cartoon of the Day

* Tony Auth, NYTimes

Change This

Via Firedoglake, I read about the unfortunate controversy regarding the Jena 6. This time, it's not about the teens themselves, but relates to the fundraising efforts by the online advocacy group, Color of Change, which was initially formed in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina. See False allegations on the Michael Baisden Show. I wrote about Color of Change when I discussed the rallies in support of the Jena 6, in Jena. Howard Witt of the Chicago Tribune (who has followed the Jena 6 story in the media), in Questions about Jena case funds, describes the accusations:

Just weeks after some 20,000 demonstrators protested what they decried as unequal justice aimed at six black teenagers in the Louisiana town of Jena, controversy is growing over the accounting and disbursing of at least $500,000 donated to pay for the teenagers' legal defense.

Parents of the "Jena 6" teenagers have refused to publicly account for how they are spending a large portion of the cash, estimated at up to $250,000, that resides in a bank account they control.

Michael Baisden, a nationally syndicated black radio host who is leading a major fundraising drive on behalf of the Jena 6, has declined to reveal how much he has collected. Attorneys for the first defendant to go to trial, Mychal Bell, say they have yet to receive any money from him.
Apparently, questions have arisen with respect to how the funds that have been raised by the various organizations are being spent. However, as Witt reports, Color of Change appears to be one entity that can account for all the funds raised and disbursed:
Only one national civil rights group, Color of Change, has fully disclosed how the $212,000 it collected for the Jena 6 via a massive Internet campaign has been distributed. The grassroots group, which has nearly 400,000 members, has posted images of cancelled checks and other signed documents on its website showing that all but $1,230 was paid out in October in roughly equal amounts to attorneys for the Jena youths.

Yet that transparency did not halt acrimony over the fundraising from breaking into public view on Baisden's popular radio show this week, when Baisden invited Bell's father, Marcus Jones, to accuse Color of Change founder James Rucker of misapplying the donated funds.

Jones offered no evidence for his assertion. But Baisden told his listeners that Rucker "sounds shady to me," before promoting his own fundraiser, scheduled for this weekend, which aims to collect at least $1 million for the Jena 6 and other black defendants across the country.

* * * *
Color of Change officials call Baisden's broadcast comments slanderous and say they are contemplating legal action.

"We are trying to clear our good name," said Mervyn Marcano, the group's spokesman. "It's distressing that right now the conversation around the Jena 6 is on a 'Jenagate' that doesn't exist, not the actual issues of how justice is administered in that town."

On Friday, after several prominent African American bloggers criticized Baisden for his comments, the radio host issued a statement apologizing to Color of Change "for not seeking more reliable sources."
I wonder if Baisden is a Republican -- he sure acts like one. Although he has not disclosed any information regarding his own fundraising actvities, he makes all sort of vague accusations about the group on his radio show, without any support or evidence to back it up. Color of Change has all of the supporting documentation on their website, which looks completely in order.

As for Baisden's apology -- you've heard of damming with faint praise? His "response" is the apology equivalent, see Response to Color of Change. See also, Baisden Apologizes, Displaces Blame. Baisden basically says that he "was given inaccurate information" -- so sorry. After ruining someone's reputation, intentionally or not, you would expect a wee bit more regret. But no. Instead, just to maintain a little uncertainty about things, he adds this: " We do, however, respect the right of four of the Jena 6 families who have insisted that ColorofChange discontinue collection of any monies on their behalf. But this should not reflect on the integrity of this organization which has collected and distributed over $200,000 to their legal defense." What does that mean? Now, why would the families do that, when Color of Change distributed 100% of the funds collected, when Baisden won't even disclosed how much he received, never mind how much has been collected.

Several bloggers have suggested that this whole brouhaha by Baisden is solely for ratings purposes.
See Michael Baisden's "Jena-Gate" a Sham for Ratings and Michael Baisden Attacks Color of Change. I don't know the man -- I listen to NPR myself, so I can't say.

No matter the reason -- attacking, without good cause, a group of people trying to help others is unconscionable. Even worse, it is things like this that make individuals reluctant to contribute to any entity, because they worry that the funds won't end up being used for the proper purposes. That's the real shame of this. With Bush & the boys, federal funds aren't there to help people in need. Contributions from the public are often the only help there is, so if that is impacted because of negative stories like this, there will be no help for those suffering from various catastrophes.

The New Normal

Noting that our own negative view of ourselves as a county rivals that of Pakistan and Turkey, Frank Rich labels us "a people in clinical depression," in his latest NYTimes column, The Coup at Home. Comparing the events in Pakistan with General Musharraf to those on the floor of the Senate, Rich states:

As Gen. Pervez Musharraf arrested judges, lawyers and human-rights activists in Pakistan last week, our Senate was busy demonstrating its own civic mettle. Chuck Schumer and Dianne Feinstein, liberal Democrats from America’s two most highly populated blue states, gave the thumbs up to Michael B. Mukasey, ensuring his confirmation as attorney general.

So what if America’s chief law enforcement official won’t say that waterboarding is illegal? A state of emergency is a state of emergency. You’re either willing to sacrifice principles to head off the next ticking bomb, or you’re with the terrorists. Constitutional corners were cut in Washington in impressive synchronicity with General Musharraf’s crackdown in Islamabad.
Even worse is the Bush/Musharraf analogy:
General Musharraf has always played our president for a fool and still does, with the vague promise of an election that he tossed the White House on Thursday. As if for sport, he has repeatedly mocked both Mr. Bush’s “freedom agenda” and his post-9/11 doctrine that any country harboring terrorists will be “regarded by the United States as a hostile regime.”

* * * *

But there’s another moral to draw from the Musharraf story, and it has to do with domestic policy, not foreign. The Pakistan mess, as The New York Times editorial page aptly named it, is not just another blot on our image abroad and another instance of our mismanagement of the war on Al Qaeda and the Taliban. It also casts a harsh light on the mess we have at home in America, a stain that will not be so easily eradicated.

In the six years of compromising our principles since 9/11, our democracy has so steadily been defined down that it now can resemble the supposedly aspiring democracies we’ve propped up in places like Islamabad. Time has taken its toll. We’ve become inured to democracy-lite. That’s why a Mukasey can be elevated to power with bipartisan support and we barely shrug.

This is a signal difference from the Vietnam era, and not necessarily for the better. During that unpopular war, disaffected Americans took to the streets and sometimes broke laws in an angry assault on American governmental institutions. The Bush years have brought an even more effective assault on those institutions from within. While the public has not erupted in riots, the executive branch has subverted the rule of law in often secretive increments. The results amount to a quiet coup, ultimately more insidious than a blatant putsch like General Musharraf’s.

More Machiavellian still, Mr. Bush has constantly told the world he’s championing democracy even as he strangles it. Mr. Bush repeated the word “freedom” 27 times in roughly 20 minutes at his 2005 inauguration, and even presided over a “Celebration of Freedom” concert on the Ellipse hosted by Ryan Seacrest. It was an Orwellian exercise in branding, nothing more. The sole point was to give cover to our habitual practice of cozying up to despots (especially those who control the oil spigots) and to our own government’s embrace of warrantless wiretapping and torture, among other policies that invert our values.

Even if Mr. Bush had the guts to condemn General Musharraf, there is no longer any moral high ground left for him to stand on. Quite the contrary. Rather than set a democratic example, our president has instead served as a model of unconstitutional behavior, eagerly emulated by his Pakistani acolyte.

Take the Musharraf assault on human-rights lawyers. Our president would not be so unsubtle as to jail them en masse. But earlier this year a senior Pentagon official, since departed, threatened America’s major white-shoe law firms by implying that corporate clients should fire any firm whose partners volunteer to defend detainees in Guantánamo and elsewhere. For its part, Alberto Gonzales’s Justice Department did not round up independent-minded United States attorneys and toss them in prison. It merely purged them without cause to serve Karl Rove’s political agenda.

Tipping his hat in appreciation of Mr. Bush’s example, General Musharraf justified his dismantling of Pakistan’s Supreme Court with language mimicking the president’s diatribes against activist judges. The Pakistani leader further echoed Mr. Bush by expressing a kinship with Abraham Lincoln, citing Lincoln’s Civil War suspension of a prisoner’s fundamental legal right to a hearing in court, habeas corpus, as a precedent for his own excesses. (That’s like praising F.D.R. for setting up internment camps.) Actually, the Bush administration has outdone both Lincoln and Musharraf on this score: Last January, Mr. Gonzales testified before Congress that “there is no express grant of habeas in the Constitution.”

To believe that this corruption will simply evaporate when the Bush presidency is done is to underestimate the permanent erosion inflicted over the past six years. What was once shocking and unacceptable in America has now been internalized as the new normal.

Rich is so right.

I sometimes do despair at what Bush and his cronies have wroth upon us all. He has ruined this country in innumerable ways -- both domestically and abroad and I worry whether we will be able to recover once these people are done. Of course, a part of me wonders whether they will leave -- or will try a Musharraf-type coup (after all, Blackwater is building up troops on the homefront and may soon be expelled from Iraq).

On the other hand, if power does pass to the Democrats, I have no doubt that some of the worst excesses, such as all of this executive power stuff, will go the way of the Edsel. The Republicans will flip that switch instantly and will espouse policies like limited presidential powers, as they did re: filibusters and vetoes. Perhaps that will start the correction that's needed for the country. One could only hope. The alternative is "a people in clinical depression."

Friday, November 09, 2007

As Though We Needed An Excuse

An interesting article from the Wall Street Journal's Science Journal, on the effects of optimism and pessimism in our lives. Robert Lee Hotz discusses the value of positive psychology in Except in One Career, Our Brains Seem Built for Optimism, stating:

Two research teams exploring the anatomy of expectations offer a new perspective on the power of a positive outlook. For the first time, scientists at New York University have mapped the upbeat brain -- finding in a cluster of neurons the size of a martini olive the seed of a sunny outlook on life. At its core, the brain is built for optimism, their work suggests.

Far from deforming our view of the future, this penchant for life's silver lining shapes our decisions about family, health, work and finances in surprisingly prudent ways, concluded economists at Duke University in a new study published in the Journal of Financial Economics. "Economists have focused on optimism as a miscalibration, as a distorted view of the future," said Duke finance scholar David T. Robinson. "A little bit of optimism is associated with a lot of positive economic choices."

* * * *

Optimists, the Duke finance scholars discovered, worked longer hours every week, expected to retire later in life, were less likely to smoke and, when they divorced, were more likely to remarry. They also saved more, had more of their wealth in liquid assets, invested more in individual stocks and paid credit-card bills more promptly.

Yet those who saw the future too brightly -- people who in the survey overestimated their own likely lifespan by 20 years or more -- behaved in just the opposite way, the researchers discovered.

Rather than save, they squandered. They postponed bill-paying. Instead of taking the long view, they barely looked past tomorrow. Statistically, they were more likely to be day traders. "Optimism is a little like red wine," said Duke finance professor and study co-author Manju Puri. "In moderation, it is good for you; but no one would suggest you drink two bottles a day."

* * * *

The influence of optimism on human behavior is so pervasive that it must have survival value, researchers speculate, and may give us the ability to act in the face of uncertain odds.

Medical evidence is suggestive. Optimistic people at risk for skin cancer are more likely to use sunscreen. Optimistic coronary artery bypass patients are more likely than pessimists to be taking vitamins, eating low-fat foods and joining a cardiac-rehab program five years after surgery -- and living longer, studies show.

"If even half the time our actions work out well, our life is going to turn out for the better," Dr. Phelps said. "If you are pessimistic, you are unlikely to even try."

Indeed, the researchers suspect that the breakdown of this brain network may contribute to clinical depression. All in all, Dr. Seligman said, optimists tend to do better in life than their talents alone might suggest.

I would say (despite my rants on political matters) that in my personal life, I am by nature a positive person. If anything, I may be overly optimistic, which sure doesn't sound like a good thing.

However, the article had one caveat on the value of the power of positive thinking:

Except lawyers.

Surveying law students at the University of Virginia, he found that pessimists got better grades, were more likely to make law review and, upon graduation, received better job offers. There was no scientific reason. "In law," he said, "pessimism is considered prudence."

How true. Caution is the touchstone of a good lawyer.

And you wonder why lawyers always give you the worst case scenario when you ask them a question about a legal problem. You thought it was just a CYA reaction -- making sure they tell you all of the possible pitfalls in order to avoid liability. Now you know -- if they are good lawyers -- they can't help themselves. It's just their nature.

Tags:

Rove Alert


I know George Bush was in town recently, trying to scare Republicans who were up for election in the Montgomery County suburbs, For some, Bush visit comes at a bad time, but did Karl Rove slip into town as well?

The City Council-at-Large seat is still up for grabs in Philly, with 7 votes difference between challenger David Oh and incumbent Jack Kelly, see Oh still has Kelly by 7. See also, Still no winner in Oh-Kelly Council race. The above flyer may have had something to do with the close race.

According to A.J. Daulerio of Philly Magazine's blog, The Daily Examiner, Jack Kelly Haters Literally Pulled Out the Gay Boy Scout Cards in an Attempt to End His Council Reign:

Over the last month, the alliteratively named Citizens Opposed to Politicians Who Pander to Perverts (COPPP) placed hundreds of copies of the above flyer under the windshield wipers of parishioners parked at local churches during mass.
Of course, the reference is to the fact that the City of Philadelphia determined that rent free offices provided to the Boy Scouts would violate the City's anti-discrimination policies, which include protections on the basis of sexual preference. As the Inquirer explained, City hikes Boy Scouts' rent by $199,999 over gay ban:
Cradle of Liberty officials have said they could not renounce the scouts' long-established policy of not opening membership to atheists or openly gay people without running afoul of their charter with the scouts' National Council.

City officials have said they could not legally rent taxpayer-owned property for a dollar a year to a private organization that discriminates.

The land belongs to the City of Philadelphia but has been leased since 1928 for that token sum to the scouts, who built the landmark Beaux Arts building.
Clearly, under a 2000 Supreme Court ruling in Boy Scouts of America v. Dale, the Scouts are permitted to discriminate as a private club, but the City doesn't have to acquiesce by granting them free rent if they chose to do so. Freedom sometimes has consequences. However, the decision to charge FMV rent (of $200,000/year) for the space has not been popular. Thus, the poster.

Looks like pure Rove to me.

SOS

It's definitely SOS time: Shame on the Senate.

They voted late last night to confirm Michael Mukasey, as Attorney General, despite his stance on torture (pro) and executive power (unlimited). See Mukasey Wins Vote in Senate, Despite Democrats’ Doubts.

Next up for Senate to Sell Our Souls is a vote on the FISA amendments and telecom immunity. Specter floats compromise on FISA telecom immunity. Specter is supposedly proposing a "compromise" on immunity. Of course, in Specterese, that means he's giving away the store -- our rights. The Senate Judiciary Committee has postponed a vote on the bill until next week. SJC To Vote On Surveillance Bill Next Week. Spenser Ackerman of TPM thinks it's to make the bill more palatable. Either that, or the delay is meant to give the Senate a break from the bad press over approving Mukasey despite his stand on torture before they do the same on FISA.

At this point, no one can seriously argue any more that the only spying that occurred was of the "bad guys" in other countries. As if there was any doubt, former AT&T employee Mark Klein has exposed that lie, by revealing that AT&T was involved with the NSA to capture all of our communications -- phone, email, internet. AT&T Whistleblower: Telecom Immunity Is A Cover-Up.

And the whole argument by the telecom companies that they just responded to the government's requests during a time of emergency is just baloney. As described in Scholars and Rogues, Ignorance is no excuse for telecoms in NSA illegal spying case, the legal departments of these companies knew better than anyone what was permitted under the law. Hell, I believe that they were involved in drafting the law, so I would think they knew precisely what was permissible and what was not. And if it were at all within the realm of reason to argue that it was within legal requirements, immunity wouldn't be so important.

The only "interesting" question I have about all of this is whether the grant of immunity could constitutionally be given if the underlying conduct is unconstitutional. I'm certainly not a constitutional scholar, but if the spying done by the government, with the assistance of the telecom industry, was unconstitutional, can Congress grant immunity or is that an unconstitutional act of Congress as well? Of course, it would take years of litigation to get the answer to that question and with the conservative bunch on the Supreme Court, who knows how they come down on the issue anyway.

Wednesday, November 07, 2007

Both Sides Now

Today is the birthday of a favorite singer as well as the anniversary of the death of a favorite first lady, who was an inspiration to women in politics.

Shaun Mullen of Kiko's House writes a touching essay on Eleanor Roosevelt: An Appreciation. Born October 11, 1884, see She Never Cursed the Dark, she died 45 years ago today. As he observes:

Roosevelt, who died 45 years ago today, was the first First Lady in the modern mold, which is to say not merely an obedient wife and smiling hostess at White House functions, but a hands-on presidential helpmate and a force in her own right. In fact, she was one of the most powerful influences in civil and women's rights during the four decades that straddled the middle of the last century, something that no First Lady – including Mrs. Clinton – can claim.

* * * *
Eleanor Roosevelt did not consider herself to be a feminist. That is incidental to her life story as it should be to Hillary Clinton's. Or for that matter any other woman in the public arena who should be judged for her accomplishments, not her gender. Be that as it may, I happen to believe that Roosevelt was a classic feminist:

A woman who insisted on having a life in addition to her husband's.

A woman who was able to turn her vulnerabilities into strengths.

A woman whose inner beauty shined through her physical self.

And a woman who was a powerful advocate for social justice to whom we all owe an enormous debt.
See also, Doris Kearns Goodwin, Eleanor Roosevelt, who noted that she was America's most influential First Lady who blazed paths for women and led the battle for social justice everywhere. For a local connection, she was also involved with the American Friends Service Committee related to the plight of miners in Pennsylvania and West Virginia. The Eleanor Roosevelt Connection.

And for a little bit of Both Sides Now is Joni Mitchell, who was born on this day in 1943.


Cartoon of the Day


* Kevin Siers, Charlotte Observer

Tuesday, November 06, 2007

Cartoon of the Day

* Signe Wilkinson, Philadelphia Daily News

Will She or Won't She?

It was a close call. As I drove home from work this afternoon, I almost decided to bag it.

Although I'm feeling much better since my surgery, my stamina still isn't totally recovered, so I'm pretty tired by the end of the day. That, combined with the fact that the election in Philly was pretty much decided in May, made me less than enthusiastic about voting. I went back & forth about whether it really mattered in this particular election.

In the end, the deciding factor may well have been Teresa Carr Deni. I wanted to be sure to vote against her retention on the Municipal Court and there were a few others that I wanted to vote for (Judge Debra Todd for Supreme Court, Christine L. Donohue & Judge John Milton Younge for Superior Court, & Ellen Green-Ceisler for Court of Common Pleas).

But Judge Deni holds a special spot. She's the Muni Court Judge that made the news for a recent ruling in a rape case, where she ruled there was not enough evidence to move forward with rape charges against a man accused of raping a prostitute at gunpoint. Instead, Deni said the appropriate charge was armed robbery for "theft of services." See Hooker raped and robbed - by justice system?. As the NYTimes noted, Judge Criticized in Rape Case:

A bar association has criticized a judge for refusing to uphold sexual assault charges against a man accused of making friends rape a prostitute he had hired. The judge, Teresa Carr Deni of Municipal Court in Philadelphia, said she considered the case “theft of services.” Judge Deni heightened the furor when she defended herself to The Philadelphia Daily News. “She consented, and she didn’t get paid,” the judge told the paper. “I thought it was a robbery.” The man, Dominique Gindraw, was accused of ordering the woman at gunpoint to have sex with three men. The judge dismissed the charges of rape and sexual assault on Oct. 4, but upheld those of robbery and false imprisonment. The chancellor of the Philadelphia Bar Association, Jane Leslie Dalton, said: “The victim has been brutalized twice in this case, first by the assailants, and now by the court. We cannot imagine any circumstances more violent or coercive than being forced to have sex with four men at gunpoint.”
See also, Bar Comes Out Against Judge's Ruling in Rape Case. Well, she made her decision & I made mine. I hope she goes.

UPDATE (11/10): Unfortunately, Deni was not denied retention to the bench, see 'Hooker Judge' is not denied, but justice is . . .. This is unfortunate, but not unexpected. It's why judges should not be elected. People just don't pay attention to these races.

Monday, November 05, 2007

Remember the 5th of November

Although I am familiar with Guy Fawkes Day celebrations in England, I didn't really know the story behind the holiday. Scott Horton provides historical background and a comparison to the environment existing in this country today at Harpers in Happy Counterterrorism Day:

On November 5, Britain remembers Guy Fawkes and the Gunpowder Plot. Fawkes, an ensign, had taken the lead in a 1605 plot to blow up the houses of Parliament at Westminster as part of a Catholic effort to bring down the Protestant monarchy in England. He was apprehended—allegedly in the act itself—taken to the Tower, and subjected to torture. For centuries, Guy Fawkes Day marked the event. Englishmen were taught of the need to be vigilant in the defense of the realm, and particularly to remember the threat from within, from the disloyal Catholics. But mostly they enjoyed the privilege of lighting bonfires and engaging in pranks on a chilly autumn evening.

But today Britons have a take on Guy Fawkes that is much at odds with the historical one. Once Fawkes was a symbol of the traitor within. The people were called to be on guard against his like. No longer. Today Guy Fawkes is increasingly viewed as the heroic figure prepared to stand against an unjust and oppressive state, as a martyr and a victim of torture.
We would do well to follow their lead. Continuing my rant against our slide into a torture state, see We've Come Undone, Horton notes the lessons of that incident, including the fact that torture never works and is always wrong. Despite being tortured in the Tower of London, no information was obtained from Fawkes as a result. Drawing further parallels to today, he also adds that we should be wary of the government that rules by fear and finally, that a government that rules by stereotypes is unjust. After the Guy Fawkes fallout, Britain retaliated and did to Catholics what is being done to Muslims today. Read the piece -- it's worth it.

And for Keith Olbermann's Special Comment on Torture, see George Bush’s Criminal Conspiracy of Torture at Crooks & Liars.

Cartoon of the Day

* Drew Sheneman, Star-Ledger

We've Come Undone




I can't express how extremely upset I still am by the fact that Mukasey's nomination as Attorney General appears to be a forgone conclusion, despite his stance on torture and executive power. See You Suck, Chuck. This Countdown video features Keith Olbermann discussing the situation with Richard Wolfe of Newsweek and Former Nixon White House Counsel, John Dean. See also, TPM's post, Dean on Mukasey, for Dean's reminder of the "direct situational and historical parallels with Judge Mukasey’s nomination to be Attorney General and that of President Richard Nixon nominating Elliot Richardson to be Attorney General during Watergate."

However, what was truly shocking to me was the revelation that a former DOJ official, Daniel Levin, the then acting assistant attorney general, "charged with reworking the administration's legal position on torture in 2004 became so concerned about the controversial interrogation technique of waterboarding that he decided to experience it firsthand." Afterward, he became convinced that it was torture and began revising the Department's memos on torture, but was fired by Gonzales before he completed his memo requiring tighter controls on interrogation techniques. See White House Blocked Waterboarding Critic.

Has it really come to this? Is there nothing that this county stands for in the "post 9/11 world" other than terror? Whether it's that we are paralyzed by terror or we are intent on inflicting terror on others. Glenn Greenwald of Salon expresses the state of our sad moral compass, in Mukasey's nomination and the sudden opposition to "waterboarding":

What Judge Mukasey believes is, without question, radical and disturbing. His beliefs -- from the power of the President to violate Congressional statutes to limitless war powers to the authority to order barbaric interrogation methods -- would have been unthinkable six years ago in an Attorney General. But now, it and he are well within mainstream Beltway ideology, thanks to some combination of acquiescence and active support from the core of both political parties. And there is something deeply artificial and manipulative about a Congress that has decided to permit all of these things to take root to pretend suddenly that they are so offended by them, that what Mukasey believes crosses their bright lines so clearly that he cannot be confirmed.

If Mukasey's nomination were rejected (and the likelihood that Democrats will actually take this or any other stand seems very low), it seems as though the most significant impact would be to allow Senate Democrats to claim that they took a stand for critical principles -- principles that they have permitted to be eroded and assaulted for years, when they weren't doing the eroding and assaulting themselves. And while a late defense of these principles is certainly better than none at all, it is far from clear that rejecting Mukasey's nomination would really amount to a restoration of any of these principles.

The concessions by the Senate members of the Democrat Party (a/k/a the "Icky Party") have rendered them as responsible, if not more so, for condoning torture. As Andrew Sullivan correctly points out, "the pro-torture right will use Feinstein's and Schumer's capitulation on the rule of law to advance the torture program," in The Mukasey Precedent:

The current Republican standard is that if the Congress does not explicitly forbid specific torture techniques as illegal, then they're legal. They hold that the clear and broad legal standard - "severe mental or physical pain or suffering" - is too broad and too clear to accommodate what a handful of men, i.e. Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Addington, et al. want to do with prisoners under their control.

Even though waterboarding has always been regarded as torture and is illegal under any meaningful understanding of English; even though the United States prosecuted Nazis as war criminals for performing exactly the same torture techniques now authorized by the United States under the rubric of "enhanced interrogation"; even though the United States has court-martialed soldiers for doing what the president has authorized; unless the specific techniques are entered explicitly into the law, according to Lowry, the Geneva Conventions and settled law don't apply. And so any vote for Mukasey will now be interpreted by torture advocates like Lowry and Bush administration officials as legal support for torture.
That torture would be acceptable to this Administration is the subject of a Buzzflash analysis, Channeling Bush’s Inner Sadist: An Insight Into His Obsession with Torture, which reflects upon Bush's own obsession with torture, which was noted by Doonesbury's Gary Trudeau, back in his Yale days:
Bush is a model narcissistic sociopath, who is devoid of the ability to empathize. It is the characteristic of such people to have the ability to 'appear' to be concerned about others, but that is just for show. The inner heart is empty. You can knock all you want, but you won’t find anyone home in the empathy department when it comes to sociopathic personalities.

The long-ago forgotten recollection of Garry Trudeau, as corroborated in the Yale Daily News and The New York Times, indicates quite clearly Bush’s mindset: inside of the 'great hugger' is a 'great sadist.'
Upon reading this, I was reminded of my earlier post where I noted Bush's affinity for torture based upon his frat days, in December of 2005 in He's still just a Frat Boy.

And since it's come to this, in case a history lesson on waterboarding is needed, Marty Lederman of Balkinization provides it, in Waterboarding Through the Ages.

And as a final somewhat warped humorous note, PA's own Senator Specter has surprisingly announced his plan to vote in favor of Mukasey. Specter Says He Will Back AG Nominee. Specter is like a big puff of smoke -- lots of stuff happening in the mist and then, when it goes away -- there's nothing there. Just like him, lot's of sound and noise and fury, followed by his capitulation to the party's demands. (Of course, he started in political career as a democrat, so that must be where he learned how to be so spineless).

(Video via Crooks and Liars)

Saturday, November 03, 2007

Cartoon of the Day

* Tom Toles, NYTimes

Ms. Sportsmanship



So soccer season has ended.

I must confess that I'm not much of a soccer mom, since I don't even know the basics of the game. I've attended a few games and cheered when it seemed as though I should. On the other hand, my athletic husband (who's a major sports fan) more than makes up for my lack of sports savvy. He's the unofficial team cheerleader.

The season was special in many ways. The girls Friends Select Soccer team was able to field a Varsity Soccer team after a several year hiatus. See They're Back. They were featured in the Inquirer, see United They Play, about their new coach and team building efforts. In the end, although they didn't have a winning season, they did win the Friends School League Junior Varsity tournament in mid-October at the George School.

And, for me at least, the best part of all happened last Thursday, when Friends Select held its Fall Athletic Sports Assembly. My daughter received the Varsity Girls Soccer Sportsmanship Award. I don't have to be a sports fan to know that's the ultimate achievement.

(Picture of award with photo of soccer team senior class members)

~ ~ ~ ~
I think sportsmanship is knowing that it is a game, that we are only as a good as our opponents, and whether you win or lose, to always give 100 percent.

- Sue Wicks

Perfection



The brilliantly witty folks at BarelyPolitical have done it again. The latest video from the Philly-based team that did the SNL spoof "Box in a Box," followed by the "I've Got A Crush On Obama" video, along with the continuing saga of Giuliani Girl and the supporting- the-troops number "I Like A Boy," has moved into a whole new shtick.

As Garling Gauge explained, in Ode to “Perfected Jew” Ann Coulter:

In response to Republican author Ann Coulter’s recent statement that Christians are “Perfected” Jews, the Barely Political team have added a faux-ode to their increasing repertoire of popular online faux-political videos.
Rachel Sklar of Huffington Post, in Perfected: The Ann Coulter Song (And The Barely Political Business Model), notes that "Singer/songwriter [and Philly girl] Leah Kaufmann, . . . steps out from behind the mike to get in front of the camera, for the first time." She adds:
The song itself definitely follows the Barely Political template of sardonic punchlines ('She's got the hottest Adam's apple at the Republican conventions') and pop-culture observations ('Wanna come over later and watch 'Seinfeld' together?' with a picture of Michael Richards), but it's got a specific target this time, and good-natured spoofery with zingers is ratcheted up with some sharper twists of the knife — the most effective of which is letting Coulter be Coulter in the form of voice-overs and spliced-in footage mixed into the song. It's incredibly effective to build up through Coulter's various verbal affronts to decency right up to what remains her piece de resistance, her sliming of 9/11 widows, leading into Kaufman's final breathy 'Just like Ann Coulter..' as the guitar strums and fades out.
In trying to figure out the best way to respond to the ugliness that is Ann Coulter (and her ilk), I recently said -- let's make fun of them. See Speak Now or Forever Hold Your Silence. This was just what I was looking for.

As much as I like politics, and as important as many of the issues that face us are, I still like to keep a sense of humor about it all. That's why I like Jon Stewart, Bill Maher & Stephen Colbert.

The latest entree into this "hallowed" field is the "Perfected: The Ann Coulter Song" video.

I began a post on humorous sites such as "Barely Political" in August that I never got around to finishing. According to The Hilarious Road to 2008 Wired:
Other media corporations are also experimenting with online political humor video sites, as Sklar points out. They include HBO/AOL's "This Just In," Comedy Central's "Indecision 2008," The Onion's "Onion News Network," and The Huffington Post's own 23/6.

Thus the election of 2008, which promises to be one of the most pivotal in both US and world history, may also end up as one of the funniest, and most entertaining ever.

Definitely check out those sites. Much laughter promised.

For more on Barely Political, see Huffington Post, A Crush on Obama, And An Eye On The Prize and The Latest From Obama Girl: Breaking The Mold. See also, Paul Levinson's Infinite Regress, The Barely Political Revolution.

UPDATE (11/4): For more on the Philly angle of Barely Political crew, see The woman behind Obamagirl revealed, from Dan Rubin, who occasional stills posts at his Bling Blog. The Inquirer's business blog also notes that Barely Political website was recently sold, Philly's "Obama Girl" Playboy-babe site is sold, but that offices will remain in Philly.

Friday, November 02, 2007

Match-the-Candidate.com

Via Thrillist (by way of The Huffington Post), I took a quiz that matched me with the candidate that's the perfect match for me.

Glassbooth will recommend the presidential candidate you should vote for based on your worldview, covering issues such as social security, Iraq and the environment. Based upon your responses, Glassbooth will tell you the candidate most aligned with your positions.

So, who's the man (or woman) for me? Based upon what I consider to be the important issues, the candidate of my dreams:

Dennis Kucinich shares a 94% similarity with your beliefs.

Very Similar on Civil Liberties, Environment, Health Care, Taxes, Iraq.
Similar on Gun Control.

John Edwards shares a 83% similarity with your beliefs

Very Similar on Health Care, Taxes, Iraq, Environment, Civil Liberties.
Similar on Gun Control.
I assume the differences in the order of the issues as listed between Kucinich and Edwards is based upon the similarity of the various issues to my order of priority. My top priorities were Civil Liberties and Iraq, followed by Environment, Gun Control and Health Care.

Interesting.

Tags: ,

You Suck, Chuck


And Dianne, you're a Dastardly Diva.

Calling it a "difficult decision," Schumer announces his support of Michael Mukasey, Schumer, Feinstein to Support Mukasey:

The key swing votes have swung. Sens. Chuck Schumer (D-NY) and Dianne Feinstein (D-CA) say they're voting for, meaning that Michael Mukasey will make it through the Senate Judiciary Committee and almost certainly be confirmed as the next attorney general.
As the NYTimes put it, Schumer and Feinstein Back Mukasey:
The statement from Mr. Schumer of New York, and late word from the office of Senator Feinstein of California that she too would endorse Mr. Mukasey, virtually assured that he would win the backing of the Judiciary Committee when it meets on Tuesday, and in all probability confirmation by the full Senate.

There are nine Republicans on the Judiciary Committee, versus 10 Democrats. So with the support of Mr. Schumer and Ms. Feinstein, the numbers are on Mr. Mukasey’s side, even though Senator Patrick J. Leahy, the Vermonter who heads the Judiciary Committee, this afternoon became the fifth Democrat on the panel to announce that he would vote against the nominee.
Bush & his cronies like to dig the Democrats by referring to them as the "Democrat Party" -- leaving off the "ic." As usual, the Republicans have it backwards. All that's left of the emasculated party is the "ic" part. They should be call the Icky Party instead.

* Brett Penrose, Comics Sherpa

Just Say No

* To Attorney General nominee Michael Mukasey, who doesn't seem to understand that like porn, torture is something that you just know when you see it, Nominee’s Stand May Avoid Tangle of Torture Cases.

* To telecom immunity or further erosion of our privacy rights, America Is Watching You and With Democrats Like These ....

* To Blackwater, Heat Builds On Blackwater: Congresswoman Moves To Ban Private Security Contractors.

* To Bush on Iran, Senators warn Bush has no authority on Iran and Inexorable march toward war with Iran?.

* To further funding the civil war and chaos in Iraq, Another $200 Billion.

* And last, but certainly not least, to Democrats acting like spineless, cowardly, vacillating clowns, The Soft Underbelly of the Democratic Party.